Homemade Pumpkin Spice and Pumpkin Spice Caramel Coffee Creamers

Pumpkin spice season has a way of finding its way into just about everything, but coffee may be one of its very best destinations. Homemade Pumpkin Spice and Pumpkin Spice Caramel Coffee Creamers give you two choices for bringing those familiar fall flavors to your morning cup: a classic Pumpkin Spice Coffee Creamer made with sweetened condensed milk and a Pumpkin Spice Caramel Coffee Creamer made with dulce de leche.
Both versions begin with real pumpkin puree, light brown sugar, pumpkin pie spice, and vanilla, but from there they take two different paths. The classic version keeps the focus on sweet pumpkin spice flavor, while the caramel version adds dulce de leche for an entirely different option.

This is also Recipe #12 from the Black Hollow Roadside Market, where homemade jars, bottles, sweets, and baked goods have been appearing on the shelves throughout the season. These two creamers fit right in with the old-fashioned roadside-market idea: something homemade, something seasonal, and something meant to make an ordinary cup of coffee feel a little more special.
And because there are two creamers in one recipe, you don’t have to choose between pumpkin spice and pumpkin caramel. Make the one that sounds best today, or make both and turn your refrigerator into its own little fall coffee bar.
Two Bottles, Two Very Different Cups of Fall

At first glance, these two creamers look like variations of the same recipe, and in many ways they are. Both start with pumpkin puree and brown sugar. Both include pumpkin pie spice and vanilla. Both use a cooked pumpkin mixture that is strained before being combined with the creamy portion of the recipe.
The big difference comes from the ingredient that creates the creamy base.
The Pumpkin Spice Coffee Creamer uses sweetened condensed milk, while the Pumpkin Spice Caramel Coffee Creamer uses dulce de leche. That single change gives you two distinctly different choices without requiring two completely unrelated recipes.
Here is the easiest way to decide which bottle belongs beside your coffee cup.
| Creamer | Creamy Base | Flavor Direction | Finished Amount |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pumpkin Spice Coffee Creamer | Sweetened condensed milk | Classic pumpkin spice | About 14 ounces |
| Pumpkin Spice Caramel Coffee Creamer | Dulce de leche | Pumpkin spice with caramel | About 2 cups |
The difference in the finished amounts is worth noticing, especially if you’re planning to make both. The caramel version also contains more water than the classic version, so don’t assume the two recipes can be made by simply substituting dulce de leche for sweetened condensed milk. Each has its own ingredient amounts and should be followed as written.
Behind the Curtain Tip: If you’re making both creamers at the same time, label the bottles as soon as they’re filled. Their similar fall coloring can make it harder to tell which is classic pumpkin spice and which is pumpkin spice caramel just by looking at them.
Real Pumpkin Starts the Fall Flavor
These aren’t simply creamers with pumpkin pie spice stirred into a creamy base. Both recipes actually begin with pumpkin puree.
The pumpkin is combined with light brown sugar and water, brought to a full boil, and then simmered for 1 minute. From there, the pumpkin mixture goes through a fine sieve, separating the liquid from the pumpkin pulp.
That detail is important when reading the recipe because the pumpkin puree itself doesn’t remain in the finished creamer. After the mixture has been cooked, the recipe specifically instructs you to strain it, discard the pulp, and then strain the resulting syrup a second time.
So while real pumpkin is part of the process, the finished creamer isn’t intended to contain spoonfuls of pumpkin puree.
The brown sugar is added with the pumpkin at this first stage, rather than later with the milk or dulce de leche. By the time you reach the creamy portion of either recipe, you’re working with the strained pumpkin mixture rather than the original pumpkin, sugar, and water mixture.
This is one of those recipes where reading all the way through the instructions before starting is particularly helpful. There are several strainings, the saucepan gets rinsed partway through, and the vanilla isn’t added until after the creamer is removed from the heat. Knowing those details ahead of time makes the process much easier to follow.
Wow! I Never Knew That… The pumpkin you begin with isn’t the pumpkin you see in the finished bottle. After cooking the pumpkin, brown sugar, and water together, the mixture is strained, and the pumpkin pulp is discarded. The strained pumpkin syrup is what moves on to the next stage of the recipe.
The Fine Sieve Gets a Workout


Keep that fine sieve handy. You’re going to use it more than once.
After the pumpkin mixture has cooked, it is poured through a fine sieve to separate the syrup from the pulp. I use a whisk to help work the liquid through the sieve. The pulp is then discarded, but the straining isn’t finished yet. The pumpkin syrup goes through the fine sieve a second time before being combined with the remaining ingredients.
There is one more trip through the sieve at the end.
After the creamy mixture has been heated and the vanilla has been whisked in, the finished creamer is strained again before going into its glass container. With the classic version, some of the sweetened condensed milk may have clumped around the edges of the saucepan. The same can happen with the dulce de leche in the caramel version.
This final straining step is already built into both recipes, so don’t be tempted to put away the sieve after preparing the pumpkin syrup.
A simple way to keep track of the process is:
- Cook the pumpkin mixture.
- Strain and discard the pumpkin pulp.
- Strain the pumpkin syrup again.
- Prepare the creamy portion of the creamer.
- Strain the finished creamer.
- Pour into a glass container.
That isn’t a substitute for the complete recipe instructions. It’s simply a useful overview of the rhythm of both recipes. Once you understand that rhythm, the two versions are surprisingly easy to keep straight.
Sweetened Condensed Milk Keeps the Classic Version Simple
The first bottle is the straightforward pumpkin spice option. Once the pumpkin syrup has been prepared and strained, rinse the saucepan, then add the sweetened condensed milk, pumpkin syrup, and pumpkin pie spice. Everything is whisked together and heated on low until the mixture comes to a simmer. The vanilla is added only after the saucepan is removed from the heat.
The finished creamer is then strained one final time and transferred to a glass container. The recipe yields about 14 ounces of homemade creamer, made with pumpkin, brown sugar, pumpkin pie spice, vanilla, and sweetened condensed milk.
What I like about having this version alongside the caramel version is that the two don’t compete. The classic creamer gives you one direction, and the dulce de leche version gives you another. You can decide which one you want based on the kind of cup of coffee you’re craving.
And because the classic version comes first, it’s also a helpful reference point. Make it on its own, and you have pumpkin spice creamer. Make the second recipe, and you can see just how much changing the creamy base transforms the idea.
Dulce de Leche Takes the Second Bottle in a Caramel Direction
For the second creamer, sweetened condensed milk steps aside and dulce de leche takes its place.
This is Pumpkin Spice Caramel Coffee Creamer, and although it shares the same basic pumpkin-spice foundation as the first version, it has its own formula. In particular, pay attention to the water. Some is used with the pumpkin and brown sugar at the beginning, and the remaining water is added later with the dulce de leche, strained pumpkin syrup, and pumpkin pie spice.
That means the ingredient list is worth keeping nearby even if you’ve just finished making the classic version. The methods may look familiar, but the measurements aren’t identical.
Once the dulce de leche mixture is smooth and simmering over low heat, it is removed from the heat, and the vanilla is whisked in. The creamer then gets its final trip through the fine sieve before being poured into a glass container.
This version yields 2 cups, another difference to keep in mind if you’re preparing containers ahead of time.
Behind the Curtain Tip: Don’t rely on memory when moving from the first creamer to the second. The Pumpkin Spice Caramel Coffee Creamer uses water in two separate additions, while the classic Pumpkin Spice Coffee Creamer does not. Keep the caramel recipe in front of you as you work.
From Roadside Market Shelf to Morning Coffee

Recipe #12 adds something new to the Black Hollow Roadside Market collection because these creamers aren’t baked goods, candy, toppings, or jarred pantry ingredients. They’re made specifically with the coffee cup in mind.
The classic Pumpkin Spice Coffee Creamer fits naturally into the fall setting, but the Pumpkin Spice Caramel Coffee Creamer connects especially well with the other caramel flavors found throughout the market. Together, the two bottles give the coffee side of Black Hollow its own little moment.
Presentation can be simple. A glass container lets the creamer itself be part of the display, while a label makes the two flavors easy to identify. If both are going onto the table at the same time, keeping their names clearly visible matters more than adding elaborate decoration.
These would also be fun to bring out when serving fall desserts. Instead of thinking of the creamer only as something to grab on a weekday morning, place the bottles beside a pot of coffee when dessert is served and let everyone choose between pumpkin spice and pumpkin spice caramel.
It’s an easy detail, but it ties the coffee into the fall dessert table rather than treating it as an afterthought.
One Recipe Idea, Several Ways to Serve It

These creamers are obviously made for coffee, but even within that one purpose, there are several ways to use the two-flavor concept.
For everyday mornings, keep your favorite version ready for your regular cup. When you’re entertaining, put both on the table and let guests choose. For a fall brunch, use them as part of a small self-serve coffee station. When dessert is being served, bring the creamers back out with the coffee so the fall flavor continues through the end of the meal.
You can also turn the two bottles into a simple tasting idea. Start with the classic Pumpkin Spice Coffee Creamer in one cup of coffee and try the Pumpkin Spice Caramel Coffee Creamer in another. Because both start with pumpkin, brown sugar, pumpkin pie spice, and vanilla, the comparison really comes down to what happens when the creamy base shifts from sweetened condensed milk to dulce de leche.
If you’re serving a group, don’t forget that the two recipes produce different amounts. The classic makes about 14 ounces, while the caramel makes about 2 cups. Planning your containers before you begin means you won’t be searching for the right bottle while the warm creamer waits in the saucepan.
A Few Details Worth Knowing Before You Begin
This isn’t a complicated recipe, but it does have a few details that are easy to overlook if you skim the instructions.
- Use pumpkin puree, not a pumpkin mixture with other ingredients already added. Have a fine sieve ready before you begin, as it will be used repeatedly. You’ll also need a bowl beneath the sieve when separating the pumpkin syrup from the pulp.
- A whisk plays an important role throughout the process. In addition to whisking the ingredients together in the saucepan, I use it to work the liquid through the fine sieve during the first straining.
- The recipes also call for a full boil across the whole surface before the heat is turned down and the pumpkin mixture simmers for one minute. That’s more specific than simply seeing a few bubbles around the edge of the saucepan, so watch the surface rather than just the sides of the pan.
- Finally, remember the order of the vanilla. In both recipes, it is whisked in after the creamer has been removed from the heat. Following the written sequence keeps the two versions consistent, even though their creamy bases differ.
No Coffee Required: Take These Fall Flavors to the Mixing Bowl

Here’s the fun twist about homemade coffee creamer: you don’t actually have to like coffee to enjoy it. These Pumpkin Spice and Pumpkin Spice Caramel Coffee Creamers can skip the coffee cup and head straight into your fall baking.
Think of each creamer as a flavored liquid ingredient. The classic Pumpkin Spice Coffee Creamer brings together pumpkin, brown sugar, pumpkin pie spice, vanilla, and sweetened condensed milk, while the Pumpkin Spice Caramel Coffee Creamer takes those fall flavors in a caramel direction with dulce de leche. That gives you two ready-made flavor combinations to experiment with in desserts.
Try a splash in muffins, quick breads, cupcakes, cakes, pancakes, or waffles for a little extra fall flavor. The classic version is the natural choice when you want to keep the focus on pumpkin spice, while the caramel version opens the door to combinations with apple, pumpkin, pecan, spice, and brown sugar desserts.
Don’t forget about everything that happens after the baking, either. A little creamer can be mixed with powdered sugar to make a fall-flavored glaze to drizzle over loaf cakes, muffins, scones, cinnamon rolls, or Bundt cakes. Start with a small amount and add more until the glaze reaches the consistency you need. Use Pumpkin Spice Creamer for a classic fall glaze or Pumpkin Spice Caramel Creamer when you want to add a caramel note.
The creamers can also be experimented with in buttercream and other frostings. Because they’re sweetened flavored mixtures rather than plain milk, don’t assume they can replace all the milk or liquid in an existing recipe measure for measure. Start small, taste as you go, and adjust the recipe you’re making as needed.
| Beyond the Coffee Cup | Pumpkin Spice | Pumpkin Spice Caramel |
|---|---|---|
| Muffins & quick breads | ✓ | ✓ |
| Cupcakes & cakes | ✓ | ✓ |
| Powdered sugar glazes | ✓ | ✓ |
| Frostings | ✓ | ✓ |
| Pancakes & waffles | ✓ | ✓ |
| Apple desserts | ✓ | ✓ |
| Pumpkin desserts | ✓ | ✓ |
| Pecan desserts | ✓ | ✓ |
So even if a pumpkin spice latte has absolutely no appeal to you, don’t rule out these recipes. No coffee required. Make a bottle for the mixing bowl instead, and suddenly “coffee creamer” becomes one more ingredient you can reach for when you’re dreaming up fall desserts.
Behind the Curtain Tip: Before you finish the bottle, save a little creamer for a quick powdered sugar glaze. You don’t need much liquid to transform powdered sugar into a drizzle for a loaf cake, muffin, or other fall treat.
Make-Ahead Planning Without the Morning Rush

Homemade coffee creamer is much more convenient when the cooking, straining, and cleanup happen before you’re standing in the kitchen waiting for that first cup of coffee.
Both recipes finish by being poured into glass containers, making them easy to prepare ahead of time. Once made, keep the creamers refrigerated rather than leaving them on the coffee bar between uses.
If you’re preparing both versions for a brunch, dessert table, or fall gathering, make them ahead so your coffee station only needs to be assembled when it’s time to serve. Labeling the containers in advance is especially useful because the two flavors are closely related.
Before serving, check the creamer in its container and stir or shake it if needed before adding it to coffee.
For a Black Hollow Roadside Market display, the decorative setup and the actual serving of the creamer can also be treated separately. The bottles can maintain a market-ready look, while the creamer itself stays properly chilled until it’s time to pour.
Two Fall Favorites from One Homemade Idea

What makes this recipe especially useful is the choice.
Instead of offering a single pumpkin spice creamer, it gives you two distinct versions built around the same fall flavor theme. One combines the pumpkin-spice mixture with sweetened condensed milk. The other pairs it with dulce de leche for Pumpkin Spice Caramel Coffee Creamer.
The repeated straining, separate formulas, and final simmer give each creamer its own complete method rather than presenting the caramel option as an afterthought. At the same time, the shared pumpkin, brown sugar, vanilla, and pumpkin pie spice keep the two bottles connected.
Make one when you know exactly what you’re craving. Make both for a fall brunch, coffee bar, dessert table, or simply because choosing between pumpkin spice and pumpkin spice caramel seems completely unnecessary when you can have both.
And for the Black Hollow Roadside Market, two homemade fall coffee creamers seem right at home among all those jars and bottles waiting on the shelves.

Shop the Black Hollow Roadside Market
Welcome to the Black Hollow Roadside Market, a curious little roadside stand where the shelves are crowded, the lanterns are glowing, and there’s always something homemade waiting to be discovered. What began as a collection of fall flavors has turned into a market filled with jars of caramel and fruit toppings, handcrafted extracts, cozy spice blends, freshly baked treats, old-fashioned candies, and a few delightfully spooky surprises.
This page is your guide to everything on the shelves at Black Hollow. Each item you see in the market has its own recipe, from pantry staples like Apple Pie Spice and Pure Vanilla Extract to seasonal favorites like Apple Cider Caramel Sauce, Mini Ube Cheesecakes, Candy Corn Cookies, and all the other treats that have found their way to the stand.
Some recipes were created especially for Black Hollow, while others are longtime Lady Behind the Curtain favorites that were simply too good to leave behind. Together, they make up one wonderfully mismatched little roadside market filled with things that are homemade, baked, bottled, and made for sharing.
So wander through the shelves, peek inside the jars, and see what looks good. Every recipe from the Black Hollow Roadside Market is gathered below, and as new treats arrive at the stand, you’ll find them added here.
THE MARKET IS OPEN. COME SEE WHAT'S ON THE SHELVES.
Homemade Pumpkin Spice and Pumpkin Spice Caramel Coffee Creamers
I hope these two homemade coffee creamers add a little fall flavor to your morning coffee. I love that one recipe gives you two choices: classic Pumpkin Spice Coffee Creamer and Pumpkin Spice Caramel Coffee Creamer.
Make your favorite, or make both and create a little pumpkin spice coffee bar of your own. They would be such a fun addition to a fall breakfast, brunch, or dessert table, especially when everyone gets to choose which flavor goes into their cup.
And if you’ve been following along with the Black Hollow Roadside Market, we’ve now made our way to Recipe #12. I love seeing all of these homemade fall recipes come together on the market shelves, each one adding something different to the collection.
However you serve these creamers, I hope you enjoy them, share them with the people gathered around your table, and pour yourself a good cup of coffee while you’re at it.
♥ Sheryl
LATEST POSTS
Homemade Pumpkin Spice and Pumpkin Spice Caramel Coffee Creamers
Ingredients
For the Pumpkin Spice Coffee Creamer:
- ½ cup pumpkin puree
- ½ cup light brown sugar, packed
- ½ water
- 1 (14-ounce) can sweetened condensed milk
- ½ tablespoon vanilla extract
- ½ tablespoon pumpkin pie spice
For the Pumpkin Spice Caramel Coffee Creamer:
- ½ cup pumpkin puree
- ½ cup light brown sugar, packed
- 1 cup + 2 tablespoons water, divided
- 1 (13.4-ounce) can dulce de leche
- ½ tablespoon vanilla extract
- ½ tablespoon pumpkin pie spice
Instructions
For the Pumpkin Spice Coffee Creamer:
- In a medium saucepan, add the pumpkin, brown sugar, and water.
- Whisk together, bring to a boil (across the whole surface), turn down the heat, and simmer for one minute.
- Place a fine sieve over a bowl and strain the pumpkin mixture to separate the syrup from the pumpkin pulp. Discard the pulp. TIP: I used the whisk to work the liquid through the sieve.
- Pour the syrup through the fine sieve again.
- Rinse out the saucepan, then add the sweetened condensed milk, the strained pumpkin syrup, and the pumpkin spice.
- Whisk together, then continue whisking until the creamer is smooth; cook on low heat until it comes to a simmer.
- Remove from the heat and whisk in the vanilla.
- Pour the creamer through a fine sieve again. Some of the condensed milk may have clumped around the edges of the pan.
- Pour the creamer into a glass container. MAKES ABOUT 14 OUNCES
For the Pumpkin Spice Caramel Coffee Creamer:
- In a medium saucepan, add the pumpkin, brown sugar, and ½ cup + 2 tablespoons water.
- Whisk together, bring to a boil (across the whole surface), turn down the heat, and simmer for one minute.
- Place a fine sieve over a bowl and strain the pumpkin mixture to separate the syrup from the pumpkin pulp. Discard the pulp. TIP: I used the whisk to work the liquid through the sieve.
- Pour the syrup through the fine sieve again.
- Rinse out the saucepan and add the dulce de leche, the strained pumpkin syrup, pumpkin spice, and the remaining ½ cup of water.
- Whisk together and continue whisking until the creamer is smooth; on low heat, cook until it comes to a simmer.
- Remove from the heat and whisk in the vanilla.
- Pour the creamer through a fine sieve again. Some of the dulce de leche may have clumped around the edges of the pan.
- Pour the creamer into a glass container. MAKES 2 CUPS

Pumpkin Spice Creamer Questions from the Coffee Pot
Two similar recipes naturally bring up a few questions, especially when the ingredients and methods overlap. These answers focus on the small details that can help you understand the differences between the two versions without repeating the complete recipe instructions.
- Are Pumpkin Spice Coffee Creamer and Pumpkin Spice Caramel Coffee Creamer the same recipe with one ingredient swapped? No. Although they share several ingredients and many of the same methods, their measurements differ. The caramel version also divides its water between two stages of the recipe, so follow the individual recipe rather than treating dulce de leche as a direct one-for-one replacement.
- Do I leave the pumpkin pulp in the creamer? No. After the pumpkin mixture is cooked, it is strained, and the pulp is discarded. The liquid that passes through the sieve is strained again before moving on to the creamy portion of the recipe.
- Do I really need to strain the pumpkin mixture twice? The written method calls for two strainings of the pumpkin syrup, followed by another straining of the finished creamer. Since that repeated straining is part of the recipe, keep the fine sieve nearby until the creamer is completely finished.
- Why is my finished amount different between the two flavors? The recipes don’t have identical formulas. The classic Pumpkin Spice Coffee Creamer makes about 14 ounces, while the Pumpkin Spice Caramel Coffee Creamer makes about 2 cups.
- Can I use the same saucepan for the entire recipe? Yes. The method specifically calls for rinsing out the saucepan after preparing and straining the pumpkin mixture. The cleaned saucepan is then used for the creamy portion.
- When does the vanilla go into the creamer? Vanilla is added after the saucepan has been removed from the heat in both versions. It’s one of the steps the two recipes share, so look for it near the end rather than adding it with the pumpkin mixture at the beginning.
- What should I do if I see clumps around the edge of the saucepan? Don’t skip the final straining. The recipe notes that sweetened condensed milk or dulce de leche may clump around the edges of the pan. The finished creamer goes through the fine sieve before being transferred to its glass container.
- Which version should I make first? Either one can stand on its own. Choose Pumpkin Spice Coffee Creamer for the classic version, or Pumpkin Spice Caramel Coffee Creamer if the dulce de leche version sounds better. If you can’t decide, making both is exactly why this recipe is called Homemade Pumpkin Spice Coffee Creamer, Two Ways.
With those small details out of the way, there’s really only one decision left: which bottle gets poured into the first cup?


I hope these two homemade coffee creamers add a little fall flavor to your morning coffee. I love that one recipe gives you two choices: classic Pumpkin Spice Coffee Creamer and Pumpkin Spice Caramel Coffee Creamer.
Comments
Homemade Pumpkin Spice and Pumpkin Spice Caramel Coffee Creamers — No Comments
HTML tags allowed in your comment: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>